World Wide Panorama mailing list archive

Mailinglist:wwp@yahoogroups.com
Sender:Alex Makienko
Date/Time:2006-Feb-08 15:34:00
Subject:Patent war?

Thread:


wwp@yahoogroups.com: Patent war? Alex Makienko 2006-Feb-08 15:34:00
Hi All,

I am ready to release my stitching tool - PanoLab.

BUT.

I've decided to review once again all the patent war issues (I have already 
the "book" of prints regarding that). From the common sence and scientific 
point of view I didn't violate any of existing patens and intellectual 
property. I've based on my own research and public domain sources known for 
decades. I did not use any of existing source codes (except of JPEG 
impotr/export open source library with appropriate reference), etc. etc. 
etc. However I suppose that I used the same fundamental geometry equations 
as all other developers :-).

But justice and common sence are two different things. We all know that the 
term "fisheye" and all basic equations were introduced by prof. Robert Wood 
in 19th century but not by IPIX in the end of 20th. We all know that a 
general mapping and image stitching technology I've based on exists for 
decades and is a public domain for many years. But I am concerned that I am 
trying to enter a difefrent world where common sence doesn't work and wheel 
becomes known only after issuing appropriate patent... I have no intention 
to waste my time and fight with lawers. I may try to release PanoLab for 
public but is there a high degree of risk to be involved in the "VR patent 
war" what I absolutely do not want to do? We all remember Helmut's story... 
:-(

Any ideas or advises?

Cheers,
Alex Makienko


Next thread:

Previous thread:

back to search page