wwp@yahoogroups.com:
Re: fisheye lenses : Nikkor 10.5 mm vs Sigma 15
pedro_silva58 2005-Mar-31 20:29:00
hi all!
i've followed this thread with interest, hoping someone would compare
the nikon and the sigma 15mm (yes, not the 8). they are comparable
(both full frame, etc), and i'm considering getting one of them. the
sigma is cheaper, as expected, but is it worse? anyone has experience
with these, and would be willing to share? links ok too!
tia and cheers,
pedro
--- In #removed#, Uri cogan <#removed#> wrote:
>
> I started off with a sigma 8mm and moved to the Nikon 10.5
>
> The Nikon is sharper, and being "full frame" the image is a bit
> larger than the Sigma (I use a Nikon D70 camera).
>
> In terms of work flow it's about the same for me (6 shots all
around,
> one up and one down). Chromatic aberration is easy to fix using
> Photoshop's "Camera Raw" filter. Vignetting is less than the Sigma,
> but I it was never an issue for me since Xblend takes care of it
> really nicely.
>
> The Sigma however is a very nice lens, and I've seen some really
> excellent work done with it.
> --
>
> Uri Cogan
> http://www.uricogan.com
>